Flat-Rate Interest and the Cost of Borrowing
Compare flat-rate and reducing-balance loan interest using the same advance and term. See how a smaller printed rate can produce a higher total cost.
In this chapter
Intermediate
Flat-rate interest is calculated using the original amount borrowed throughout the loan term. Borrow $1,200.00 at a flat rate of 12% a year for one year and the interest is $144.00. That calculation uses the original $1,200.00 even as your instalments repay parts of the loan.
Calculate the interest, then spread the total across payments
With a flat annual rate, multiply the original principal by the rate and the loan length in years. If the agreement spreads principal and the resulting interest equally across the payments, add them and divide by the number of payments.
\[ I_{\mathrm{flat}}=L f T,\qquad M=\frac{L+I_{\mathrm{flat}}}{n} \]
\(L\) is the original loan amount, \(f\) is the quoted flat annual rate as a decimal, \(T\) is the term in years, \(I_{\mathrm{flat}}\) is total interest, \(n\) is the number of payments and \(M\) is the regular payment. If the term is six months and the rate is annual, \(T=0.5\). A loan with a fixed rate can also use a reducing balance. “Fixed” describes whether the rate changes. “Flat” describes the principal used to calculate interest.
Worked example. Two ways to apply a 12% quote
You borrow $1,200.00 today, at time zero, and make 12 equal payments at the ends of months one through 12. Both quotes are fixed, with no fees, taxes or extra payments. Values are USD. You receive the principal and pay the instalments. The table shows interest and payment amounts as positive magnitudes.
| Item | 12% annual flat rate | 12% nominal annual rate on a reducing balance |
|---|---|---|
| Interest basis | Original $1,200.00 throughout | Principal outstanding each month |
| First month’s interest (USD) | $12.00 | $12.00 |
| Regular payment (USD) | $112.00 | $106.62 |
| Total interest (USD) | $144.00 | $79.42 |
| Total paid (USD) | $1,344.00 | $1,279.42 |
For the reducing-balance loan, divide its nominal annual rate by 12 to get 1% per month. The loan amount equals the present value of its 12 month-end payments at that rate. Solving that equation gives the fixed monthly instalment. In month one, both methods start with the same principal and charge $12.00 in interest. In month two, the flat schedule still allocates $12.00 to interest. The reducing-balance schedule charges 1% of the principal left after payment one, or $11.05. The flat schedule costs $64.58 more in interest over the full term. Compute totals using full precision before rounding.
Worked example. A smaller printed rate can cost more
Keep the same $1,200.00 loan, twelve month-end payments and zero fees or taxes. Now suppose the flat offer quotes 8% per year, while the reducing-balance offer still quotes 12% nominal per year, or 1% per month. All figures are in USD.
| Offer | Interest in the first month (USD) | Regular payment (USD) | Total interest over twelve months (USD) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 8% annual flat rate | $8.00 | $108.00 | $96.00 |
| 12% nominal annual reducing-balance rate | $12.00 | $106.62 | $79.42 |
The flat lender charges 8% of the original $1,200.00 over the year, so the total interest is $96.00. Spread the $1,296.00 of principal and interest across twelve payments to get $108.00. The reducing-balance lender charges $12.00 in the first month, then calculates each interest charge on the principal still owed. After six payments, about $617.91 of principal remains, so month seven’s interest is about $6.18. The flat schedule still allocates $8.00 to interest in that month.
Across the term, the flat offer costs $16.58 more in interest. Both lenders advance the same cash at the start and use the same payment dates here. The interest calculation and the remaining balance explain why the lower quoted rate produces the higher total. Compare the repayment schedules when two labels use different bases.
What to compare on two loan offers
The same printed rate can produce different payments because the calculation bases differ. In this example, the loan amounts, payment dates and fee assumptions match, so the cash payment totals answer which scheduled outlay is larger. With different fees or dates, put every amount on its own date, including the cash you actually receive at the start. A comparable effective borrowing rate uses those cash flows and their timing.
Practice questions
Choose one answer per question. Use the stated rate and timing. Dollar amounts are in USD. Round final dollar amounts to cents.
1. Calculate six months of flat interest
A loan of $2,000.00 carries a flat rate of 10% per year for six months. What’s the total interest?
2. Find the equal monthly payment
You borrow $900.00 for one year at 8% annual flat interest, with 12 equal month-end payments and no fees. What is the payment?
3. Choose the interest base
Halfway through a flat-rate schedule you have $600.00 of principal left from an original $1,500.00 loan. The stated flat rate is 12% annually and interest is allocated evenly by month. How much of the next scheduled payment is interest?
4. Compare rate labels
Both loans have a fixed quoted rate. One charges interest on original principal and one uses the balance outstanding. What follows?
5. Explain why the costs separate
Two loans have the same original principal, tenor and positive numerical annual rate. Both pay monthly and the reducing-balance rate is nominal with monthly periods. Why is total reducing-balance interest lower if principal falls each month?
6. Find the right comparison inputs
The two offers now have different upfront fees and repayment dates. What should you use to compare their effective borrowing rates?