Capital Preservation and the Money You Need to Protect
Set a capital preservation floor for a fixed bill or a purchasing-power goal. Test shortfalls after losses, fees and inflation before the due date.
In this chapter
Beginner
Capital preservation means protecting an amount of money you need to keep available. Put a dollar figure and a date on that goal. “Keep at least $9,000.00 spendable in one year” gives you a way to test a choice. The next question is whether you need a fixed number of dollars or enough to buy something whose price can rise.
Define the floor before comparing returns
The capital floor is the minimum usable amount you want on the goal date. An investment can fall below its opening balance and still meet a floor that was set lower. It can also grow and leave you short if the required amount grew faster. Check the cash available after costs and any selling or withdrawal delays.
Worked example. Protect $9,000.00 for a dated payment
You have $9,300.00 today and owe $9,000.00 exactly one year from now. Here are two hypothetical ways to hold the money. All figures are nominal USD. Assume no taxes, interim cash flows or delay in getting the cash. Initially assume no fees. Option A has a fixed payout if paid as contracted. Option B has two illustrative one-year outcomes with no probabilities assigned.
| Choice and scenario | Spendable balance at the due date (USD) | Shortfall versus $9,000.00 (USD) |
|---|---|---|
| A, fixed payout as assumed | $9,480.00 | $0.00 |
| B, weak outcome of −8% | $8,556.00 | $444.00 |
| B, strong outcome of +14% | $10,602.00 | $0.00 |
A has a $480.00 cushion under its payment assumption. The weak B outcome leaves \(9{,}300(0.92)=\$8,556.00\), so the bill is $444.00 short. The strong B outcome gives \(9{,}300(1.14)=\$10,602.00\). For a floor you must meet, the strong result gives you extra spending money only in that outcome. Check the weak case on its own. A forecast range for B gives useful scenarios. A contractual payment for A gives a different kind of evidence, and still depends on who owes it and when you can collect it.
Recheck the floor after costs and price changes
Worked example. A fee and a goal priced in today’s dollars
Suppose both choices now cost a fixed $150.00 to turn into spendable cash at year-end. A leaves $9,330.00 after the fee, so it covers the fixed $9,000.00 bill with a $330.00 cushion. B’s weak outcome leaves $8,406.00, increasing the shortfall to $594.00.
Now suppose the goal is to preserve what $9,000.00 buys today. Under a 4% inflation scenario for the relevant goods, the year-end dollar target is \(9{,}000(1.04)=\$9,360.00\). Before the fee, A’s payout would clear this target by $120.00. After the fee, its $9,330.00 comes up $30.00 short in year-end dollars. In today’s purchasing power that balance is \(9{,}330/1.04\), or about $8,971.15. B’s weak case with the fee is $954.00 short of the revised nominal target. One payout can cover a fixed invoice and fall short of a purchasing-power goal.
Use a price change that fits the goal. A general inflation rate can help with a broad spending target. If the goal is a particular course or piece of equipment, its quoted future price or a reasonable range for its price may be more relevant. See real return for how to compare purchasing power across matching dates.
Decide what counts as available
Ask what could keep the amount out of reach on the goal date. A notice period, an early-exit charge or a later-than-expected cash receipt can shrink the amount you can use. If a choice has a stated payout, read the conditions for receiving it. For a goal with several payments, set a floor at each payment date so a later surplus does not mask an earlier shortage.
Practice questions
Choose one answer per question. Use the stated assumptions and round final dollar amounts to cents.
1. Set the floor
You have $7,000.00 and must pay a fixed $6,500.00 in nine months. What floor answers whether this particular bill is funded?
2. Calculate a stressed shortage
A $5,000.00 balance faces a 12% decline by the date a $4,600.00 bill is due. No fees or other cash apply. How large is the shortfall?
3. Inflate a purchasing-power floor
A goal costs $4,000.00 at today’s prices. The relevant prices could rise 5% by the payment date. What nominal floor preserves the same buying power in that scenario?
4. Include a fee at the deadline
A choice pays $3,050.00 gross at the date you need $3,000.00. An $80.00 withdrawal fee is deducted then. What is the outcome?
5. Read an exact nominal payoff
You need $2,000.00 to settle a fixed invoice on a specific date. You have $2,000.00 of spendable cash on that date. Prices generally rose before then. What follows?
6. Check whether money is available
An investment has enough value for the floor, but the sale cash becomes available two days after the deadline. There is no other cash. Has the goal been funded on time?