Finance education, free and open.An independent learning project
THEFINANCE ARCHIVES
Finance foundationsEquitiesFixed incomeDerivativesEconomicsFinancial statementsPortfolio management
Home / Finance foundations / After-Tax Return and How Much of the Gain You Keep
Finance foundations

After-Tax Return and How Much of the Gain You Keep

Calculate before-tax and after-tax returns with different rates on dividends and sale gains. Track when each tax is paid and how it changes what you keep.

In this chapter

Intermediate

You make $190.00 on a $1,000.00 investment before tax. If $40.00 of that goes to tax, you keep $150.00 of the gain. The after-tax return is 15% under those assumptions. The before-tax return is 19%.

Give each tax a base and a date

A tax rate tells you how much of a specified amount is due. In the example below, one tax applies to the cash dividend when you receive it. Another applies to the gain when you sell. For that second tax, the gain is the sale proceeds above the purchase cost, using the basis stated in the example.

\[ R_{\mathrm{after}}=\frac{S+D-T-V_0}{V_0} \]

\(V_0\) is the amount invested at the start, \(S\) is the sale proceeds on the stated fee basis, \(D\) is cash income before tax, and \(T\) is the sum of the taxes paid within the period in this calculation. \(R_{\mathrm{after}}\) is the decimal after-tax return. Set \(T=0\) to find the comparable before-tax return. This simple setup assumes no outside flows and that interim cash earns zero interest.

Worked example. A dividend in October and a sale in April

Buy a share position for $1,000.00 on 1 April 2025. Receive a $40.00 dividend on 1 October and sell the shares for $1,150.00 on 1 April 2026. Assume tax arises and is paid at 25% of the dividend on receipt and at 20% of the positive gain on sale. These are hypothetical rules and rates. Use USD, assume no fees, credits or offsets, and leave the net dividend in cash without interest.

Date and eventCash flow before tax (USD)Tax paid on that date (USD)Cash flow after tax (USD)
1 April 2025, purchase−$1,000.00$0.00−$1,000.00
1 October 2025, dividend+$40.00$10.00+$30.00
1 April 2026, sale+$1,150.00$30.00+$1,120.00

The dividend tax is \(40(0.25)=\$10.00\). The sale tax applies to the $150.00 gain, so it is \(150(0.20)=\$30.00\). The after-tax cash you finish with is $1,150.00, made up of the $1,120.00 sale receipt after tax and the earlier $30.00 net dividend.

Calculation over the one-year holdingGain (USD)Return on $1,000.00
Before tax$190.0019.00%
After tax$150.0015.00%

Follow the tax as well as the investment

The payment dates are part of the example. If you reinvested the dividend, only the amount available after the October tax would be ready to invest. A tax paid on a later date leaves cash available in the meantime. Use the relevant dates on a cash-flow timeline when timing affects the comparison. In practice, the base, rate and timing can depend on the investment, account and applicable rules.

Worked example. The same tax bill paid on two different dates

On 1 January 2026 you invest $1,000.00 in a share position. It pays a $100.00 cash dividend on 1 July. You invest the available dividend in a separate six-month holding that grows 5% by 1 January 2027, when you also sell the original shares for $1,020.00. Compare two hypothetical rules that both tax the July dividend at 20%, a bill of $20.00. One takes the tax on 1 July. The other collects it on 1 January 2027. Assume no other taxes or fees and use USD.

Treatment of the July dividendCash invested on 1 July (USD)Value on 1 January before any tax still due (USD)Dividend investment left after all tax (USD)
No tax in the comparison$100.00$105.00$105.00
$20.00 tax paid in July$80.00$84.00$84.00
$20.00 tax paid in January$100.00$105.00$85.00

Combine each ending amount with the $1,020.00 share sale. Before tax you finish with $1,125.00, or 12.50% above your start. Paying the tax in July leaves $1,104.00, an after-tax return of 10.40%. Paying it in January leaves $1,105.00, or 10.50%.

The tax takes $20.00 in both cases. In the later-payment case that $20.00 earns 5% for six months before you pay it. The extra dollar comes from having more money invested during the interval. When you compare returns after tax, record both how much cash leaves and when it leaves.

Practice questions

All amounts are in USD. Apply only the hypothetical tax rules stated. Keep any interim income in cash at zero interest. Assume no fees unless specified. Round final percentages to two decimal places.

1. Tax on the gain

You buy for $1,000.00 and sell for $1,200.00. A 20% tax applies to the gain and is paid on sale. There is no income. What is the after-tax return?

Question 1 choices

B is correct

  • A. 20% is the return before tax.
  • B. The gain is $200.00 and the tax is $40.00. The $160.00 remaining gain gives a 16% return.
  • C. This taxes the entire $1,200.00 sale receipt, including the $1,000.00 recovered from the original purchase.

2. Interest arrives after withholding

A deposit pays $80.00 of interest. A 25% tax is withheld from the interest at payment. How much of that interest reaches you?

Question 2 choices

C is correct

  • A. $20.00 is the tax withheld. The question asks how much income reaches you.
  • B. This treats the 25% rate as a flat $25.00 charge. The tax is a share of the $80.00.
  • C. \(80(1-0.25)=\$60.00\) reaches you.

3. A loss without a tax offset

You invest $1,000.00 and sell for $950.00. There is no income and the hypothetical rules give no credit or tax charge for this loss. What is your after-tax return?

Question 3 choices

A is correct

  • A. There are no tax cash flows under these rules. A $50.00 loss on $1,000.00 gives −5%.
  • B. −4% would need a $10.00 tax benefit to reduce the loss. No credit applies here.
  • C. −6% would mean an additional $10.00 cash charge. The problem gives no such charge.

4. Two taxes with different rates

You buy for $500.00, receive a $20.00 dividend and later sell for $550.00. Pay 10% tax on the dividend when received and 20% tax on the gain on sale. What is your after-tax return?

Question 4 choices

B is correct

  • A. This counts $50.00 of sale gain and $20.00 of dividend before any tax.
  • B. Pay $2.00 on the dividend and $10.00 on the gain. That leaves $58.00 above the original $500.00, or 11.60%.
  • C. This applies 20% to both the dividend and the sale gain. The dividend’s stated rate is 10%.

5. A tax is due before you sell

In a hypothetical account, a September dividend is taxed when paid. A gain on sale is taxed when you sell in December. When should these taxes appear on the cash-flow timeline?

Question 5 choices

A is correct

  • A. Place each tax on the date the question says it is paid.
  • B. Putting both taxes in December moves the dividend tax away from its September payment date.
  • C. Putting both in September charges tax on a sale that takes place in December.

6. An exit fee changes the taxable gain

A position costs $2,000.00. At sale, the buyer pays $2,250.00 and a $50.00 selling fee is deducted. The hypothetical tax is 25% of the gain after the fee and is paid on sale. There is no other income. What are the before-tax return after the fee and the after-tax return, in that order?

Question 6 choices

C is correct

  • A. Both figures omit the selling fee. The tax is then calculated on a gain of $250.00.
  • B. The first figure correctly counts the fee. The after-tax figure still charges tax on $250.00 before the fee.
  • C. Net sale proceeds are $2,200.00. The fee-adjusted gain is $200.00, and tax takes $50.00. Divide the $200.00 and $150.00 gains by $2,000.00.

Find a finance concept

Press Enter to see all matching chapters.