Return on Investment (ROI) and What a Project Earns
Calculate simple return on investment from a project's cash benefits and costs. See why projects with the same ROI can pay back on very different dates.
In this chapter
Intermediate
A shop spends $2,400.00 on a project and receives $3,000.00 from it. The project leaves a $600.00 gain. The return on investment (ROI) is 25% because the gain is one quarter of the cost. In dollars, that’s $0.25 earned for each $1.00 spent, after recovering the original dollar.
Decide what counts as the project’s gain
List the cash the project brings in and the cash it costs. Include costs you can attribute to the project, such as setup, installation and any operating costs counted in the comparison. If an asset can be sold at the end, include its sale proceeds in benefits when that is part of your scope. Keep each item on one side of the calculation.
\[ \mathrm{ROI}=\frac{B-C}{C}=\frac{G}{C} \]
\(B\) is the total cash benefit, \(C\) is the total cash cost, and \(G=B-C\) is the net cash gain, sometimes called the net cash benefit for that project. All three are dollar amounts. \(C\) must be positive. Express the ratio as a percentage. A negative ROI means the cash benefits fell short of the costs you counted.
Worked example. Two label printers with the same ROI
A shop is choosing between two label-printing projects. Each starts on 1 January 2026. Each requires $2,000.00 for equipment and $400.00 for setup on that date. Each then produces a single $3,000.00 cash benefit from a contract. Project A pays after one year and Project B after three years. Assume no other cash flows, financing charges, taxes or reinvestment. The amounts are in USD.
| Project cash flow (USD) | 1 January 2026 | 1 January 2027 | 1 January 2029 |
|---|---|---|---|
| A | −$2,400.00 | +$3,000.00 | $0.00 |
| B | −$2,400.00 | $0.00 | +$3,000.00 |
For each project, the gain is \(3{,}000-2{,}400=\$600.00\), so the simple ROI is \(600/2{,}400=25\%\).
Project A gets the shop’s cash back two years earlier. It could use that money to buy more equipment or pay a bill during those two years. A net present value calculation can put the two schedules on a common date using an appropriate discount rate. Simple ROI adds up the dollar amounts as stated, regardless of when they arrive. Use annualised return to convert an observed holding-period result to a yearly equivalent.
Read what the percentage includes
Ask which costs and dates sit behind an ROI figure. An estimate that counts only equipment can give a higher ROI than one that also counts installation and operating expenses. The number is easiest to compare when the projects use a consistent cost basis and you can see their payment schedules. For a position you bought and later sold, its holding-period return gives the result over those dates.
Worked example. Savings are part of a project’s benefit
A lunch shop is considering a new freezer on 1 January 2026. The equipment and installation cost $600.00 together. Keeping the old freezer would cost $1,000.00 in electricity per year. The new one would cost $700.00 per year over a three-year comparison. The new freezer needs $120.00 of extra maintenance at the end of year two. At the end of year three the shop can sell it for $90.00. Assume the old unit has zero resale value, the same rent applies either way, and there are no other cash flows, fees, taxes or reinvestment. Use undiscounted USD amounts and place each year’s savings at year-end.
| Date | Cash benefit from choosing the new freezer (USD) | Cash cost from choosing it (USD) |
|---|---|---|
| 1 January 2026 | $0.00 | $600.00 |
| End of year one | $300.00 of electricity saved | $0.00 |
| End of year two | $300.00 of electricity saved | $120.00 |
| End of year three | $300.00 saved plus $90.00 resale | $0.00 |
| Total | $990.00 | $720.00 |
Each $300.00 saving is the difference between the two electricity bills. The saving is a cash benefit because the shop keeps money it would otherwise spend. The rent is the same in both cases, so choosing the new freezer adds zero rent to the comparison.
Subtract the $720.00 cost from $990.00 of benefits to get a $270.00 gain. The ROI is \(270/720=37.50\%\) over the three-year project. If a supplier quotes 65% by comparing the same benefits with the $600.00 equipment and installation cost alone, that figure leaves the maintenance out. Check which costs the reported ROI counts before using it to compare two projects.
Practice questions
Use simple undiscounted cash ROI. All amounts are in USD and before tax. Assume no cash flows beyond those stated.
1. A machine’s basic ROI
A machine costs $1,200.00 and brings in $1,500.00 in cash over its life. What is its ROI?
2. Counting all the costs
A display costs $800.00 to buy and $200.00 to install. It brings in $1,250.00. What is the ROI including both costs?
3. Receipts fall short of the outlay
A project spends $900.00 and receives $810.00. What is the signed ROI?
4. Equal ROI, different schedules
Two projects each cost $500.00 today. One pays $650.00 in one year and the other pays $650.00 in three years. Which statement is true?
5. Adding the value recovered on sale
A shop buys a tool for $600.00. It receives $640.00 in cash benefits while using it and $80.00 when it sells the tool at the end. What is the simple ROI?
6. An extra cost later on
A cart costs $1,000.00 today and needs a $200.00 repair next year. It yields $1,500.00 in total receipts, excluding any resale. What is its ROI counting both costs?