Rating Watch and Why a Credit Rating Goes Under Review
In this chapter
Intermediate
A rating watch flags a possible near-term rating action while an agency evaluates an event or new information. S&P Global Ratings calls its designation CreditWatch. If a company rated BBB is placed on CreditWatch with negative implications, the current grade is still BBB. The watch tells you that an identifiable development could push the agency’s rating opinion lower.
S&P’s guide describes near-term CreditWatch developments as usually within 90 days. The timing of a resolution can depend on the information available and the event. Read any specific timetable in the notice. S&P can also take a rating action without a prior watch. An outlook usually covers a broader, intermediate timeframe.
Start with the event and the missing facts
| S&P CreditWatch implication | What the agency could be examining |
|---|---|
| Positive | A development that could support a higher grade |
| Negative | A development that could lead to a lower grade |
| Developing | More than one direction is possible |
Confirmation of the existing grade is also possible at resolution. A watch can be removed after a downgrade, after an upgrade or after the rating is affirmed. Read the notice for the specific object. The agency may be reviewing a named note, the issuer or several ratings at the same time.
Worked example 1. The acquisition closes as announced
Yarrow Networks announces a takeover. The fictional S&P-style notice keeps the issuer at BBB and places that rating on CreditWatch with negative implications. The agency in the example wants to know how much of the proposed $200.00 million borrowing will actually be drawn and whether the acquired business will generate the stated earnings. All amounts are hypothetical USD figures. Defined leverage here is gross debt divided by annual earnings on the notice’s basis.
| Stage | Debt (USD millions) | Defined annual earnings (USD millions) | Leverage on these assumptions |
|---|---|---|---|
| Before closing | $300.00 | $100.00 | 3.00× |
| With announced financing at closing | $500.00 | $110.00 | About 4.55× |
At release, the acquisition could still fail or close with different financing. The grade remains BBB while the agency reviews it. The deal closes six weeks later and Yarrow draws the full $200.00 million. With annual earnings defined at $110.00 million, leverage is \(500.00/110.00\), about 4.55×. In this hypothetical outcome the agency downgrades the issuer to BBB− and removes it from CreditWatch. The later notice records the actual one-notch change.
Worked example 2. The same deal is cancelled
Use the same first announcement and the same initial BBB negative CreditWatch. This time a required approval fails in week six and the parties terminate the deal. Assume no break fee, no borrowing is drawn and there is no other material change affecting the rating. Yarrow still has $300.00 million of debt and $100.00 million of defined earnings. Leverage stays at 3.00×.
| At resolution | Acquisition completed | Acquisition cancelled |
|---|---|---|
| Agency announces | Downgrade to BBB− | Affirmation at BBB |
| CreditWatch after the notice | Removed | Removed |
| Was there a transition in the grade? | Yes, one notch lower | No grade change |
The event that prompted the watch now has a different outcome. In the cancelled case, the agency affirms BBB and removes the watch. Removal alone would tell you that special review ended. To see whether the credit grade moved, read the action on the grade in the same announcement.
Keep the sequence of notices
Record the event date, the grades placed under watch and the stated implications. Then record the date and wording of the resolution. A portfolio rule could treat watched bonds differently during review. Apply that rule to the watch status, then separately apply any rule that uses the current grade. If you are counting changes in a ratings history, use the rating actually assigned at resolution.
Practice questions
Choose one answer per question. Use the stated assumptions and round final results only. Any dollar amounts are in USD.
1. Read a watch announcement
An issuer rated BBB− is placed on CreditWatch negative. The notice says the grade is unchanged. Which rating remains in the current-grade field?
2. Read the usual timeframe
Which event is most like S&P’s near-term use of CreditWatch in this lesson?
3. Calculate the debt effect
A company has $240.00 million of debt and $80.00 million of defined annual earnings. A deal adds $60.00 million of debt and $20.00 million of annual earnings. What is post-deal leverage on the stated basis?
4. Read resolution without a downgrade
A negative watch is removed and the agency affirms BBB. How should a rating-transition table record the grade outcome?
5. Read developing implications
A deal can close with equity funding or substantial debt. The agency places the grade on CreditWatch developing. What does the designation indicate?
6. Find the target of the review
A notice puts one named note on watch and says the issuer grade is affirmed. What should a holder check first?