Secured and Unsecured Debt and What Collateral Changes
In this chapter
Intermediate
If the borrower pledges a building for one bond, holders of that bond may have a claim on the building’s proceeds. Holders of an unsecured bond rely on their claim against the issuer and the estate available to that class. Secured debt has an enforceable claim on specified collateral under the bond and security documents. The difference shows up in where the first recovery dollars come from and how any shortfall gets treated.
Start with the legal issuer of the corporate bond. Then identify the entity that owns the pledged assets and which obligation the lien secures. A lien is a legal interest in the specified property. A first lien in the example below gets the first dollars from the collateral under the stated rules. Other deals may have multiple liens, shared security or limits on the creditor’s ability to recover from the rest of the borrower’s assets.
Build two pools of proceeds
Harbor Equipment has $100.00 of first-lien secured debt, $100.00 of other senior unsecured debt and $80.00 of subordinated debt. All amounts are in USD. Use the following hypothetical liquidation rules for both cases. They are part of the setup for the exercise.
| Pool or claim | How the case treats it |
|---|---|
| Pledged asset | Net sale proceeds go first to the secured claim up to the amount owed |
| Deficiency | Any unpaid part of the secured claim joins the other senior unsecured debt |
| General estate | $100.00 of unpledged assets, plus any surplus from the pledged asset |
| Senior unsecured class | Shares the available general estate in proportion to admitted claim amounts, up to those amounts |
| Subordinated class | Receives any balance after the senior unsecured class has been paid, up to the junior claim |
Net proceeds already exclude liquidation costs. There are no other claims or guarantees, and distributions occur together. For a claim in a class with other claims of equal rank, pro rata means each creditor receives the same percentage of its admitted claim. Work out the claim sizes after allocating the collateral. Doing that first keeps the secured creditor’s claim from being counted twice.
Worked example 1. The pledged asset sells for $70.00
Allocate all $70.00 to the secured creditor. The unpaid $30.00 joins the senior unsecured class. That class now has $130.00 of claims against a $100.00 general estate.
The shortfall claim receives \(30.00/130.00\times100.00\), or about $23.08. The other senior claim receives \(100.00/130.00\times100.00\), or about $76.92. The secured creditor therefore receives $70.00 from the pledged asset and $23.08 from the estate. It recovers about 93.08% of its original $100.00 claim. The other senior creditor recovers about 76.92% of its $100.00 claim. The junior class receives zero because the senior unsecured class used the entire estate.
Worked example 2. The pledged asset sells for $130.00
Keep every claim and the $100.00 of unpledged assets the same. The secured creditor receives $100.00 from the pledged asset and is paid in full. The $30.00 surplus enters the general estate, which now has $130.00. The other senior creditor gets its full $100.00. The remaining $30.00 flows to the junior class, covering 37.50% of its $80.00 claim.
| Allocation (USD) | $70.00 collateral | $130.00 collateral |
|---|---|---|
| Secured creditor from collateral | $70.00 | $100.00 |
| Secured creditor from general estate | $23.08 | $0.00 |
| Other senior unsecured creditor | $76.92 | $100.00 |
| Subordinated creditor | $0.00 | $30.00 |
| Total distributed | $170.00 | $230.00 |
The sale produces an extra $60.00. Under these claims and priorities, roughly $6.92 more goes to the secured creditor, $23.08 more goes to the other senior creditor and $30.00 goes to the junior class. The pledge directs the first part of the collateral proceeds. Once the secured creditor is paid, the general priority rules decide who benefits from the surplus.
Read the security package
Compare the creditor’s enforceable interest with the value likely to be available after costs. An asset’s appraisal on the day the bond is issued can be very different from net sale proceeds years later. Check who has a competing claim and whether the bond covers future assets or only listed assets. Ask what happens if that collateral leaves the group. Finally, find the rule that governs the deficiency. In a nonrecourse case that limits the creditor to the collateral, Harbor’s $30.00 deficiency would have no claim in the general estate under that assumption. The rest of the waterfall would then have to be recalculated.
Practice questions
Choose one answer per question. Use the stated assumptions and round final results only. Any dollar amounts are in USD.
1. Allocate an undersecured claim
A secured creditor has an $80.00 claim against $50.00 of net collateral proceeds. The agreement and case rules allow a senior unsecured deficiency claim. What amount joins that class?
2. Allocate a collateral surplus
A first-lien creditor with a $65.00 secured claim has sole security on assets that produce $92.00 net. The case sends surplus to the general estate. How much goes to that estate?
3. Share one estate
A $20.00 allowed deficiency shares $90.00 of estate cash with an $80.00 equal-ranking unsecured claim. What does the deficiency recover from the estate?
4. Find the collateral
A bond is unsecured and its issuer owns two warehouses. What can you conclude about the bond from those facts alone?
5. Read a nonrecourse case
Under stated nonrecourse terms, the creditor’s only recovery is $55.00 of net collateral proceeds. The amount owed is $90.00. How much does the creditor recover in total?
6. Separate value from sale proceeds
A pledged machine is appraised at $100.00. It sells for $74.00 and the sale costs $4.00. The claim is $90.00. What is available for the first-lien claim from the sale?