Asset Class Selection and What Each Asset Adds to a Portfolio
In this chapter
Intermediate
A portfolio might need one group of investments to grow over ten years and another to pay a bill next June. Asset class selection is choosing the exposures that can do those jobs. An asset class groups investments that share broad economic exposures or return and risk characteristics. Stocks and bonds are familiar examples. For a particular job, you may need a more specific group, such as short government bonds or longer lower-rated company bonds.
A class name is a starting point. Ask what actually makes the holding gain or lose value, what could happen when you need to sell, and how it behaves alongside the exposures you already have.
Start with the job
| Portfolio job | What to check in a possible exposure |
|---|---|
| Cover a dated bill | Usable currency, possible sale value at the deadline and when cash would settle |
| Carry long-term growth | What drives profits or cash flows, how wide the range of outcomes is and how long losses could last |
| Reduce sensitivity to another holding | Whether the exposures rely on different drivers, especially during a common stress |
| Match a liability with similar timing | How payment dates, interest-rate sensitivity and issuer credit align with the liability |
To compare two candidates, use the same measurement date and ask what would make each fail. A broadly diversified stock fund still has stock market exposure. Two bond funds might both hold hundreds of securities while their credit risk and sensitivity to rate changes differ markedly. Diversification depends on the risks that positions share as well as the number of names they hold.
Worked application 1. Two bond exposures for a spending job
A training centre sets aside a $32,000.00 sleeve on 30 June 2027. It must cover a $30,000.00 USD payment one year later. All distributions are reinvested through the sale date. Assume both candidates settle in time, no tax or trading charges, and use hypothetical one-year nominal USD total returns.
The team compares a short government bond sleeve P with a longer lower-rated corporate bond sleeve C. A sleeve is a group of holdings assigned a particular job. The planners use expected returns of 3% for P and 6% for C. They also test an equity downturn in which government rates fall and credit weakens.
| Exposure | Expected value at stated planning return | Total return in equity-downturn scenario | End value in that scenario |
|---|---|---|---|
| P. Short government bonds | $32,960.00 | +1% | $32,320.00 |
| C. Longer lower-rated corporate bonds | $33,920.00 | −4% | $30,720.00 |
Both can pay the bill in this scenario. P leaves $2,320.00 after the payment and C leaves $720.00. The extra expected return on C comes with exposure to two risks important to this job. It has greater duration, a measure of how sensitive bond prices are to yield changes. For the same small upward move in yields, the higher-duration sleeve tends to fall by more, all else equal. Its weaker credit quality can make its price more sensitive when investors demand extra compensation for lending to those companies.
Worked application 2. Rates rise and credit spreads widen
Keep the dollar bill and sale date fixed. This time government yields rise and investors demand higher yields on corporate debt relative to comparable government debt. That yield difference is a credit spread. The planners impose a one-year total return of −1% on P and −9% on C. These are scenario inputs, with price changes and coupon income already reflected in them.
| Exposure | Stress total return | Sale value | Cash left after reserving the bill |
|---|---|---|---|
| P. Short government bonds | −1% | $31,680.00 | $1,680.00 |
| C. Longer lower-rated corporate bonds | −9% | $29,120.00 | −$880.00 |
The $2,000.00 starting cushion can absorb at most a 6.25% loss before the bill becomes underfunded. That is the cushion divided by the $32,000.00 opening balance. A 9% decline uses up that room. Under this stress requirement, the longer corporate sleeve fails the spending job, even though it had the higher expected value. A different, longer-term job could come with more room to bear those losses.
Describe each exposure in enough detail to use it
A short investment description can say what the sleeve may hold, which currency matters to the investor, what benchmark helps describe the exposure, and what would make it unsuitable for its job. Then check how the chosen assets interact. One sleeve can carry credit risk through bonds, and another can carry some of the same economic exposure through shares of highly indebted issuers. When a job is tied to a deadline, revisit the sale and settlement assumption as the date approaches. Once the eligible exposures are clear, set the portfolio’s long-term weights.
Practice questions
Choose one answer per question. Dollar amounts are in USD. Round only the final result where a question calls for rounding.
1. Name the job
A portfolio needs money for a known USD bill in six months. Which candidate property is the most direct fit for that job?
2. Recognise overlapping exposure
A portfolio already holds shares of low-rated issuers and is offered their longer bonds as a diversifier. What should the team test?
3. Use the stress value
A $40,000.00 sleeve needs to fund a $37,000.00 bill. The tested loss is 9%, and proceeds settle before payment. What is the outcome?
4. Read a bond candidate
Two USD government bond sleeves have broadly similar credit quality. One has substantially greater duration. What should you expect for a small, comparable upward yield move?
5. Compare two bills
A government bond exposure passes a two-year funding test but cannot be sold and settled by next week’s bill. What is the implication?
6. Test the initial cushion
You invest $25,000.00 for a dated $22,500.00 payment. There are no other flows or costs and sale is timely. What loss uses up the full cushion?