Investment Constraints and What Limits Your Portfolio
In this chapter
Beginner
An investment constraint is a rule the portfolio has to obey. If a club needs at least $50,000.00 available for upcoming bills, “hold some cash” leaves the decision open. “Hold at least 20% of market value in usable USD cash at each month-end” gives the club a rule it can actually check.
An objective tells you what you want the money to achieve. Constraints draw the boundaries around how you can pursue it. A feasible portfolio satisfies all those rules at once. It may still fall short of a return objective, so feasibility is an early test in choosing a portfolio.
Turn the investor’s need into a rule
Ask what can hold up the plan. A bill puts a date on part of the money. A borrowing restriction limits the trades you can use. An exposure limit may apply to the total amount held directly and through funds. If you cannot tell whether a holding passes, write down what data the person doing the check needs.
| Need or restriction | Example of a checkable rule |
|---|---|
| Near-term cash | Available USD cash must be at least $30,000.00 on the business day before each listed payment |
| Exposure ceiling | Listed equity market value must be at most 40% of portfolio market value at each month-end |
| Eligible holdings | Hold deposits, approved broad equity funds and government bonds only |
| Borrowing | A purchase may proceed only if the account has enough settled cash to cover it and its charges |
| Use of an account with its own restrictions | Hold only instruments authorised by that account’s written terms and count fees and taxes on the policy’s stated basis |
An actual legal or contractual restriction should be checked against the governing document. A time or liquidity rule can be different across goals in the same household. See how investment horizon puts a deadline on the money you need.
Test rules together
Use one valuation date and a consistent denominator. A 40% equity ceiling means equity market value divided by total portfolio market value, under the rule shown here. It allows an allocation of exactly 40%. A limit a portfolio meets exactly is binding at that allocation. A portfolio with 32% equity has 8 percentage points of room on that rule. Some other limit may consume that room.
Worked application 1. Run four portfolios through a mandate
At the 31 March 2028 review, a club has $250,000.00 of USD assets and owes no money. It requires at least 20% in usable cash, at most 40% in approved equity funds, and the rest in government bonds. Assume the individual holdings qualify and all values are at the same review time. Each row allocates 100% of the money.
| Candidate | Cash | Equity | Government bonds | Passes both weight rules? |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| A | 20% | 40% | 40% | Yes |
| B | 18% | 40% | 42% | No. Cash misses by 2 percentage points |
| C | 22% | 45% | 33% | No. Equity exceeds the ceiling by 5 percentage points |
| D | 15% | 35% | 50% | No. Cash misses by 5 percentage points |
In A, $50,000.00 is in cash and $100,000.00 is in approved stock funds. Both the floor and ceiling bind. Compare B with A. B has the same equity weight and more government bonds, but its $45,000.00 cash balance is $5,000.00 short of the minimum. You have to test the cash rule even if the portfolio appears cautious in other ways.
Worked application 2. Relax one limit and rerun the tests
A planned payment is now covered by a separate bank account. The club formally changes the portfolio’s cash floor to 15% from the next review, keeping the equity eligibility and 40% ceiling. At the same hypothetical market values, the floor is now $37,500.00.
A continues to pass. B now has $7,500.00 more than the new floor, and D sits precisely on it. C continues to fail the equity ceiling even though its cash balance is ample. The extra choices are B and D. The club can now compare their return and risk without revisiting the rest of the mandate.
Write down how to check the rule
Name the observation time, measurement base and what happens on a breach. State whether market value or another specified base is used. Spell out inclusivity and any permitted time to correct a breach. If market moves push an allocation outside a limit, first identify what the rule requires and when. If a cash constraint is written as a fixed amount, check it in dollars even when a percentage monitor is convenient. A fixed dollar bill can stay the same while the portfolio value falls. Record the rule, its test date and the exception process in the investment policy statement.
Practice questions
Choose one answer per question. Dollar amounts are in USD. Round only the final result where a question calls for rounding.
1. Read the boundary
A mandate requires at least 10% cash and at most 50% equity. A proposal has 10% cash, 50% equity and 40% permitted bonds. How does it score?
2. Find the dollar ceiling
Equity may be at most 35% of a $200,000.00 portfolio. It currently holds $76,000.00 of equity. Ignoring costs, how far is it above the dollar ceiling?
3. Rerun all the limits
An account holds 12% cash and 58% equity. The cash minimum drops from 15% to 10%, and the equity cap stays at 55%. What happens?
4. Distinguish a moving denominator
A rule requires at least $25,000.00 of usable cash. The balance is $24,000.00. Falling security values lift its share from 8% to 10%. What is the rule’s result?
5. Check eligibility
A proposed fund would bring a portfolio within every weight limit. The mandate permits only funds on an approved list, and this fund is outside it. What is the result under the current mandate?
6. Identify the binding rule
A portfolio holds 12% cash and 35% equity. Minimum cash is 12% and maximum equity is 40%. Which constraint is binding?