Downside Capture and How a Fund Behaves When Its Benchmark Falls
In this chapter
Intermediate
When the benchmark had losing months, how much of its decline did the fund experience? Downside capture compares the fund with its benchmark using only periods when the benchmark’s return was negative. A reading of 40 on a scale where 100 means equal declines says the fund’s measured decline was about two-fifths as large in those periods.
The benchmark selects the months for both sides. If a fund loses money when the benchmark rises, that month tells you something about the fund and falls outside this particular statistic.
Filter the rows, then aggregate each side
Let \(D\) be the set of months where \(r_{B,t}<0\), with \(m\) months in the set. \(r_{B,t}\) is the benchmark return in month \(t\). \(r_{P,t}\) is the portfolio return on that same row. Use an appropriate benchmark and match the dates, currency, income and fee basis.
This lesson takes the geometric mean per selected month for each side. Let \(j\) stand for either \(P\), the portfolio, or \(B\), the benchmark.
\[ g_{j,D}=\left(\prod_{t\in D}(1+r_{j,t})\right)^{1/m}-1 \]
The product combines the growth factors of the selected months. Taking the \(m\)-th root expresses their combined growth as a constant rate per selected month. It does not make the selected months a continuous stretch in the actual account. On the convention used here, divide the two geometric means and multiply by 100.
\[ \mathrm{DC}=100\frac{g_{P,D}}{g_{B,D}} \]
\(\mathrm{DC}\) is the reported capture number. A report may instead divide cumulative selected-period returns or use annualised geometric returns. The transformation is nonlinear, so the number can differ even when the same rows are selected. State the convention with the result.
Worked case 1. Two losing months out of four
The table uses hypothetical nominal USD monthly total returns over the same month-ends, including reinvested income, before fees and taxes. There are no external transfers. The benchmark is a broad equity total-return index appropriate for this equity fund.
| Month ended | Benchmark total return | Fund total return | Use in downside capture? |
|---|---|---|---|
| 31 January | +5.00% | −1.00% | No |
| 28 February | −4.00% | −2.00% | Yes |
| 31 March | 0.00% | +3.00% | No |
| 30 April | −9.00% | −3.00% | Yes |
The benchmark’s two growth factors multiply to \(0.96(0.91)=0.8736\). The fund’s multiply to \(0.98(0.97)=0.9506\). The square roots of those products, each minus one, give geometric means of approximately −6.5334% and −2.5013%. Divide the unrounded fund result by the benchmark result and multiply by 100. Downside capture is 38.28.
Both sides fell over the selected months, and the fund’s decline per selected month was smaller. The fund’s January loss still matters to its full-period return. Keeping January out of downside capture prevents an up-benchmark month from answering a down-benchmark question.
Worked case 2. The portfolio gains while the benchmark falls
Keep the same benchmark, dates and return basis. A second portfolio earns +1.00% in February and +2.00% in April. Its two growth factors multiply to 1.0302. Its geometric mean is about +1.4988% per selected month.
\[ \mathrm{DC}=100\frac{\sqrt{1.0302}-1}{\sqrt{0.8736}-1}\approx -22.94 \]
The numerator is positive and the denominator negative. A negative downside capture shows the portfolio gained on aggregate over the benchmark’s down months. That can happen even with an occasional loss inside those months. It gives no guarantee about the next sell-off or the portfolio’s return over the entire window.
Read the sign with the sample size
For a sample with at least one strictly negative benchmark month and a valid benchmark series, the benchmark’s geometric mean is negative. A capture of 100 means the two geometric declines match. A reading above 100 means the portfolio’s measured decline was larger. Zero means the portfolio’s selected months compounded to a flat result. Report the number of down periods with the ratio. A single down month can dominate a short sample.
If the benchmark never falls over the selected frequency and window, there are no rows to aggregate. Report undefined with zero benchmark-down observations. A flat benchmark month is excluded under the strict negative rule. Downside deviation measures how far the fund itself falls below a stated return target.
Practice questions
Choose one answer per question. Use the lesson’s conventions unless the question specifies a change. Round only the final result.
1. Use one benchmark-down observation
Monthly benchmark returns are +3%, −8% and 0%. The fund earns −2%, −4% and +1%. What is downside capture?
2. Use the same rows for both series
The benchmark falls in May and August. The fund falls in May and September. Which fund returns enter the calculation?
3. Interpret a negative ratio
The reported downside capture is −30. What does that mean on this lesson’s convention?
4. Apply the geometric rule
In two down months the benchmark loses 2% and 8%. The fund gains 2% and loses 1%. Approximately what is downside capture?
5. Deal with a rising benchmark window
The benchmark returns +2%, 0% and +1%. What should you report?
6. Compare two reports
Both reports use the same benchmark-down months. One divides geometric monthly means and the other divides cumulative selected-period returns. What can happen?