Benchmark Selection and How to Compare Performance
In this chapter
Intermediate
Benchmark selection means choosing the reference you will use to judge a portfolio. Start with the job the portfolio was given. A fund hired to own developed-market stocks outside the U.S. needs a comparison that represents that opportunity set. The return series you choose must also measure the same dates, currency, hedging policy and kind of return.
Match the benchmark to the mandate before the period starts
A mandate sets the portfolio’s investment job and limits. It can specify the assets, regions, company sizes, investment style and currency policy. Pick the benchmark from those rules before looking at the results. The benchmark should have clear construction rules and a return series you can measure for the same period. For a portfolio designed to track an investable segment, also check that its holdings are a plausible alternative to the manager’s choices. A custom benchmark lets you turn several suitable indexes into one comparison using agreed weights and reset dates.
| Check | What to match |
|---|---|
| Investable universe | The allowed markets, asset classes, company sizes and meaningful style constraints |
| Dates | Same start and end points, with a comparable valuation basis |
| Currency and hedge | Same reporting currency, with the benchmark reflecting the mandate’s currency hedge policy |
| Income | Total return on both sides when the portfolio earns distributions |
| Fees and taxes | Document the basis for both figures. Check whether “net” refers to management fees, dividend withholding or another adjustment. |
For a single common period, subtract the benchmark’s return from the portfolio’s to get the excess return against that reference. The difference between two displayed rates is in percentage points (pp). A positive result shows the portfolio finished ahead of that reference for the period. It takes further analysis to explain why.
Worked case. Match a USD mandate with an index
Assume a portfolio is hired to hold large and mid-size stocks in developed markets outside the United States, without currency hedging. Its report uses nominal USD returns. All figures in these examples are hypothetical one-year simple returns over the same dates. For the matched comparison, the portfolio and the index include reinvested distributions and are measured before fees and taxes.
The portfolio returns 8.40%. Choose a developed ex-U.S. large- and mid-cap index, measured as a gross total return in unhedged USD. It returns 9.10%. Subtracting gives \(8.40\%-9.10\%=-0.70\) pp. The portfolio gained money and still trailed the comparable index by 0.70 points. A broad global index that includes U.S. stocks may help tell you what other markets did. Its extra markets would change the question if you used it to judge this mandate.
Keep the same portfolio result and change the benchmark series
Worked case. A price index flips the reported gap
A report shows the same index family with a USD price return of 7.20%. That series tracks price changes and excludes regular distributions. The portfolio’s return still includes them.
| Reference | Benchmark result | Portfolio minus benchmark (pp) | Comparison |
|---|---|---|---|
| Matched gross total return, USD | 9.10% | −0.70 | Portfolio trailed |
| Price return, USD | 7.20% | +1.20 | Portfolio appears to lead |
The second subtraction is arithmetically correct. Its interpretation changes because one side counts income and the other leaves it out. The difference between the two gaps is 1.90 points. It comes from the reference series and tells you nothing new about what the manager earned. Record the exact index variant in the report so someone else can reproduce the matched comparison.
A currency mismatch can be just as large. Imagine a single-country sleeve earns +10% in its own currency, while one unit of that currency becomes worth 5% fewer dollars. For an unhedged USD investor, the two effects compound. A unit of starting value grows to \(1.10(0.95)=1.045\) times its opening USD value, a 4.50% USD return. For a single foreign currency, write \(R_{\mathrm{USD}}=(1+R_L)(1+R_{\mathrm{FX}})-1\). Here \(R_L\) is the simple local-currency total return, \(R_{\mathrm{FX}}\) is the simple change in USD per unit of foreign currency, and \(R_{\mathrm{USD}}\) is the unhedged simple dollar return. Use decimals over the same dates. A multi-country index does the currency conversion across its constituents under its own rules. A hedged index uses a different currency policy. Check the series before interpreting the return gap.
Practice questions
Choose one answer per question. Round only the final result where needed.
1. Choose a benchmark for the job
A USD fund holds U.S. small-cap stocks and reports total returns before fees and taxes. Which reference is the closest fit?
2. Calculate a matched gap
A portfolio earns 6.20% and its matched benchmark earns 7.00% over the same dates. What’s the difference?
3. Interpret a flipped comparison
The portfolio’s total return is 5%. The same index reports 4% price return and 6% total return. Which statement matches the portfolio basis?
4. Read currency conversion
An unhedged position gains 8% locally, while its currency loses 10% of its USD value. What is the USD return?
5. Match the hedge
A USD fund holds foreign stocks and hedges the foreign currency risk. Which comparison fits best, with other details held fixed?
6. Choose the evaluation date
When should the main benchmark be chosen?