Make-Whole Call and How an Early Redemption Price Is Calculated
Discount a bond's specified payments at the contractual reference plus margin, apply the par minimum, and keep accrued interest from being counted twice.
In this chapter
Intermediate
A make-whole call lets the issuer repay a bond early at an amount calculated under the contract, often using the discounted value of specified remaining payments and a minimum redemption price. It replaces a simple fixed call premium with a formula.
“Make-whole” does not promise to reproduce every investor's lost opportunity. The calculation uses the contractual reference, spread, dates and minimum. Those can differ from your required return or the return you could earn after redemption.
Write the formula from the clause
Our teaching contract uses one flat annual-effective reference rate plus a margin. It says:
On a permitted coupon-date redemption, pay the greater of face principal and the present value of all remaining scheduled coupons and principal to stated maturity. Discount using the reference rate plus 0.50 percentage points. Pay accrued interest separately; immediately after the coupon it is zero.
For this particular contract:
\[ R=\max\left(F,\sum_{t=1}^{n}\frac{CF_t}{(1+d)^t}\right),\qquad d=b+s. \]
\(R\) is redemption price in USD excluding separately paid accrued interest; \(F\) is face principal; \(CF_t\) is the specified USD payment \(t\) full years after redemption; \(n\) is the final such year; \(d\) is the annual-effective discount rate; \(b\) is the reference annual-effective rate; and \(s\) is the margin on that same basis, all rates written as decimals.
The final \(CF_t\) includes principal. Do not add it again outside the sum. The maximum operator means the result cannot fall below \(F\) under this clause.
If a clause uses a different rate at each maturity, discount each payment using the prescribed curve and compounding. If it treats a later par-call date as the endpoint, do not automatically extend the payments to legal maturity.
Worked application 1. The discounted payments exceed par
Birch Engineering Inc.'s fictional senior unsecured note has $1,000 face, $60 annual coupons and maturity on 1 January 2030. It was issued on 1 January 2026, with the first coupon in 2027. The issuer gives valid notice on 15 November 2026 for make-whole redemption on 1 January 2027 immediately after paying that day's coupon. The notice window is 30–60 calendar days.
There are three remaining annual coupons after redemption, and the final one shares its date with principal. The just-paid coupon is not one of those remaining payments. All amounts are USD. Assume the flat reference is 3.0% and the margin is 0.5 percentage points, so \(d=3.5\%=0.035\).
| Remaining date | Coupon (USD) | Principal (USD) | Total \(CF_t\) (USD) | Present value at 3.5% (USD) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 January 2028, \(t=1\) | $60.00 | $0.00 | $60.00 | $57.97 |
| 1 January 2029, \(t=2\) | $60.00 | $0.00 | $60.00 | $56.01 |
| 1 January 2030, \(t=3\) | $60.00 | $1,000.00 | $1,060.00 | $956.06 |
Add the unrounded present values:
\[ PV=\frac{60}{1.035}+\frac{60}{1.035^2}+\frac{1,060}{1.035^3} \approx\$1,070.04. \]
Compare that amount with $1,000 par. The greater amount is $1,070.04, giving a $70.04 make-whole excess over par. For one note, the holder receives $60 scheduled coupon plus $1,070.04 redemption on 1 January 2027, or $1,130.04 total. No later coupons or principal follow.
The redemption calculation replaces those future obligations. It does not pay $1,070.04 and then leave the 2028–2030 payments outstanding.
Worked application 2. The minimum changes the result
Keep the same valuation date, remaining payments and contract, but use a 7.5% annual-effective reference. Add the same 0.5 percentage point margin: \(d=8\%\).
| Remaining payment | Present value at 3.5% (USD) | Present value at 8% (USD) |
|---|---|---|
| $60 in one year | $57.97 | $55.56 |
| $60 in two years | $56.01 | $51.44 |
| $1,060 in three years | $956.06 | $841.46 |
| Total before the minimum | $1,070.04 | $948.46 |
| Contractual redemption after minimum | $1,070.04 | $1,000.00 |
At 8%, the discounted stream is only $948.46. The contract nevertheless requires at least par, so \(R=\max(1,000,948.458060\ldots)=\$1,000\).
Including the already-due $60 coupon, cash that date is $1,060. The higher reference reduced the formula value enough for a different term—the par minimum—to determine the payment.
This does not mean the issuer necessarily wants to redeem at 8%. Permission, calculation and exercise are separate questions. Refinancing at a higher required rate may be unattractive.
Accrued interest needs its own instruction
Accrued interest is interest earned under the contract since the last coupon date but not yet paid. At our valuation instant just after the coupon, it is zero, so no adjustment is needed.
Away from a coupon date, read whether the discounted amount includes the interest accrued to redemption and whether that amount must be removed before applying the minimum. Some clauses then add accrued interest after the greater-of calculation. Others define the scheduled amounts to exclude it in the first place.
For a simple supplied-value illustration, suppose a different clause defines \(PV_{\text{ex-accrued}}=\$1,025\), par is $1,000 and separately due accrued interest is $15. Total redemption cash is \(\max(1,000,1,025)+15=\$1,040\). Adding $15 twice would overpay; omitting it would underpay. A complete off-coupon calculation also requires the contract's day count and fractional discount periods.
Read the rate's name and the valuation horizon
Before using a real make-whole clause, locate the reference security or curve, observation time, spread, compounding, remaining-payment definition, accrued-interest treatment, minimum and any later par-call date. A nominal rate compounded semiannually is not the annual-effective input used above.
The callable-bond lesson explains why an issuer might exercise a call. Here the calculation answers the narrower question: what would this contract require it to pay on the specified date?
Practice questions
Choose one answer per question. Use the stated contract, dates and rate convention. Hypothetical money amounts are USD; ignore fees and taxes unless stated. Round only the final displayed answer.