Callable Bonds and When the Issuer Can Repay Early
In this chapter
Intermediate
A callable bond gives the issuer the right to repay investors early on terms written into the bond. Suppose you expect three more coupons, but the issuer may repay the debt after the first one. If it exercises that right, you receive the specified redemption cash and future coupons stop. To understand what you might receive, read the call dates and prices alongside the final maturity date.
Issuers often find it attractive to call when they can refinance cheaply. The call price is the redemption amount specified for that exercise date. It can exceed face value, which means the issuer may have to pay a premium to buy out the remaining obligation. Fees, notice requirements and the availability of new funding also affect what the issuer actually does. A make-whole call uses a contractual calculation instead of this fixed call-price schedule.
Read the timetable and who controls it
Assume a synthetic USD bond with $1,000.00 face, a 6.00% annual coupon, and maturity in three years. Each $60.00 coupon is due at year-end. The issuer may redeem the entire bond only at the two specified call dates, subject to required notice. For this exercise, assume the notice can be given on time and there are no fees, taxes or other early redemption provisions. The scheduled coupon is paid separately, then the issuer may pay the call price immediately after it.
| Date measured from valuation | Scheduled cash for the investor | Issuer’s optional redemption after coupon |
|---|---|---|
| Before the first anniversary | No scheduled cash | No call allowed |
| Year 1 | $60.00 coupon if outstanding | May repay $1,020.00 |
| Year 2 | $60.00 coupon if outstanding | May repay $1,010.00 |
| Year 3 | $60.00 coupon plus $1,000.00 face if outstanding | Bond matures |
The restrictions before the first allowed date give the bond call protection against this optional redemption. The borrower holds the choice. A bondholder who wants out can look for a buyer at the market price, subject to being able to trade.
Compare the issuer’s two remaining costs
On a call date just after the coupon, compare the call price to the value then of leaving the bond outstanding, using the issuer’s comparable refinancing rate. The option-adjusted spread uses a pricing model that includes this exercise decision. If there is a later permitted call, allow for it when computing the cost of continuing. You can work backward: decide what the issuer would do at the last possible exercise date, then use that possible outcome to value continuation at the earlier exercise date. For the next two cases assume the same annual-effective refinancing rate applies to all remaining maturities and dates within each scenario. Exercise if calling costs strictly less than continuing. Treat a tie as continuation.
Worked application 1. A 4.50% refinancing rate makes year-one exercise cheaper
If the bond reached year two, the last coupon would already have been paid for that year. Continuing from there costs \(1{,}060/1.045\), or $1,014.35. Calling costs $1,010.00, so the issuer would call in year two if the bond were still outstanding.
Now go back to year one, just after that year’s coupon. Continuing would mean paying $60.00 plus $1,010.00 in year two. That costs \(1{,}070/1.045\) in year-one dollars, or $1,023.92. It costs $1,020.00 to call now, so the issuer calls at year one. The investor gets $60.00 plus $1,020.00 then, or $1,080.00, and receives zero thereafter. If replacement bonds offer less income, reinvesting that early cash leaves the investor with a different income stream.
Worked application 2. A 7.00% refinancing rate leaves both calls unused
At year two, continuation costs \(1{,}060/1.07\), or $990.65, below the $1,010.00 call. At year one, continuing therefore leaves $60.00 owed one year later and $1,060.00 owed two years later. Their combined value at the year-one decision date is $981.92, below the $1,020.00 call.
| Investor cash-flow date | Issuer refinancing at 4.50% | Issuer refinancing at 7.00% |
|---|---|---|
| Year 1 | $1,080.00 | $60.00 |
| Year 2 | $0.00 | $60.00 |
| Year 3 | $0.00 | $1,060.00 |
A rate below the coupon can still leave a call uneconomic. At 4.93%, for example, year-one continuation costs $1,019.73, slightly below the $1,020.00 call. Year-two continuation costs $1,010.20, slightly above the $1,010.00 call. The issuer skips year one and calls in year two. The investor receives $60.00 in year one and $1,070.00 in year two. Once you know the contractual schedule, you can measure price sensitivity by repricing the payment paths. Comparing those paths also helps explain how much price can rise when rates fall.
Practice questions
1. Identify the decision maker
A USD bond gives the issuer an optional call after year two. Who decides whether to use that provision?
2. Add the coupon once
At the call date a $45.00 USD coupon is payable separately and the issuer calls at $1,015.00. What is the investor’s total cash receipt that day?
3. Check eligibility
The first allowed optional call is at the end of year three. Market borrowing costs fall in year one. Under this provision, what can the issuer do at the end of year one?
4. Compare costs at the call date
The only allowed call costs $1,010.00 after today’s coupon. Continuing with the old bond costs $1,004.00 in present value, using comparable refinancing rates. Ignore fees. What is cheaper?
5. Trace the remaining coupon schedule
You hold a callable bond with annual payments, and it is called just after the year-two coupon. What scheduled cash does this bond pay you at the end of year three?
6. Explain the incentive
Why might an issuer skip a call even when comparable market rates have fallen below the coupon rate?