Money-Market Yield Conventions and Why Quoted Rates Can Differ
Translate a 90-day discount claim into bank-discount, investment and effective rates. Match price bases and annualisation before comparing quoted yields.
In this chapter
Intermediate
Two quoted annual rates can differ even when they describe exactly the same purchase and repayment. One may use face value as its denominator, another the price paid. One may annualise over 360 days, another over 365, and another may include compounding.
To compare money-market yield conventions, begin with the money changing hands and the exact holding period. Convert each quote back to a price or a matched-period return before ranking it.
One instrument, two cash flows
Our hypothetical discount claim is issued and bought on 1 January 2027 for $980 and repays $1,000 on 1 April 2027, exactly 90 actual days later. It has no interim coupons, options, fees or taxes, and payment is assumed certain. All amounts are USD.
The dollar gain is $20. The holding-period return uses the money actually invested:
\[ h=\frac{F-P}{P}=\frac{1,000-980}{980} \approx2.0408\%. \]
\(P\) is the $980 price, \(F\) is the $1,000 redemption and \(h\) is a dimensionless return over the actual 90-day term. It is not yet an annual rate.
Name the base and the annualisation
Let \(d=90\) actual days and use the stated year base \(B\), measured in days. Rates in formulas are decimals until converted to displayed percentages.
| Convention | Formula | Denominator and annualisation |
|---|---|---|
| Bank-discount quote, Actual/360 | \(r_D=(F-P)F^{-1}(360/d)\) | Gain as a fraction of face, simply annualised over 360 days. |
| Investment quote, Actual/365 Fixed | \(r_I=(F-P)P^{-1}(365/d)\) | Gain as a fraction of price, simply annualised over 365 days. |
| Implied effective annual rate on 365 days | \(r_E=(F/P)^{365/d}-1\) | Compound growth mathematically extended to a 365-day year. |
| Nominal annual, semiannual compound equivalent on 365 days | \(j_2=2[(F/P)^{365/(2d)}-1]\) | A half-year compound rate doubled to form a nominal quote. |
\(r_D\), \(r_I\), \(r_E\) and \(j_2\) name different quoted rates for the same inputs. Actual/365 Fixed means actual days in the term and a fixed 365-day annualisation base. The \(j_2\) formula uses fractional-period compound equivalence; it is not the simple short-bill investment quote merely renamed.
The nominal annual rate lesson and EAR lesson derive those general compounding relationships. Here they are applied to instrument prices.
Worked application 1. Translate the $980 purchase
The bank-discount calculation is:
\[ r_D=\frac{20}{1,000}\frac{360}{90}=0.08=8.0000\%. \]
Notice that \(20/1,000=2\%\) is the discount as a fraction of face, below the 2.0408% earned on the $980 actually invested.
The price-based simple 365-day quote is:
\[ r_I=\frac{20}{980}\frac{365}{90} \approx8.2766\%. \]
The compound annual equivalent is:
\[ r_E=\left(\frac{1,000}{980}\right)^{365/90}-1 \approx8.5383\%. \]
The nominal annual quote on a semiannual compound basis is:
\[ j_2=2\left[\left(\frac{1,000}{980}\right)^{365/180}-1\right] \approx8.3635\%. \]
| Measure for this one 90-day claim | Result |
|---|---|
| Dollar gain | $20.00 |
| Holding-period return | 2.0408% |
| Face-based bank-discount quote, Actual/360 | 8.0000% |
| Price-based simple investment quote, Actual/365 Fixed | 8.2766% |
| Nominal annual, semiannual compound equivalent, 365-day basis | 8.3635% |
| Implied EAR, 365-day basis | 8.5383% |
Nothing about the instrument improved as you moved down the table. The two cash flows remained −$980 and +$1,000.
The EAR is an annual equivalent, not evidence that you can keep reinvesting for a year at the same rate. A full year is \(365/90\) of these terms, not four exact 90-day periods.
Worked application 2. Matching conventions reverses the raw ranking
Compare two otherwise identical, certain $1,000 claims bought on 1 January and redeemed 90 days later. Claim A quotes 8.00% on a face-based Actual/360 discount basis. Claim B quotes 8.10% on a price-based simple Actual/365 Fixed investment basis.
A raw comparison says 8.10% exceeds 8.00%. Recover the prices first.
For A, rearrange the discount quote:
\[ P_A=F\left(1-r_D\frac{d}{360}\right) =1,000(1-0.08\times90/360)=\$980. \]
For B, rearrange the simple investment quote:
\[ P_B=\frac{F}{1+r_I d/365} =\frac{1,000}{1+0.081\times90/365} \approx\$980.42. \]
Keep the unrounded B price when converting its return.
| Claim | Original quote | Price per $1,000 redemption (USD) | 90-day price-based return | Simple Actual/365 Fixed quote |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| A | 8.00% discount, Actual/360 | $980.00 | 2.0408% | 8.2766% |
| B | 8.10% investment, Actual/365 Fixed | $980.42 | 1.9973% | 8.1000% |
A is cheaper for the same payment on the same date and has the higher matched return. The original annual quotes used different denominators and day bases, so their raw ordering was misleading.
If credit risk, currency, tax or liquidity differs, matching the arithmetic is still necessary but does not finish the economic comparison.
Where the “bond-equivalent” label needs care
For short bills, “bond-equivalent” or “coupon-equivalent” can mean the price-based investment yield rather than the face-based discount quote. For a bond with semiannual compounding, the phrase can also refer to a nominal annual quote equal to twice the half-year yield.
Those uses do not make the 8.2766% and 8.3635% figures interchangeable. State the convention whenever you use the label.
For a named bill market, check when its investment-yield formula applies and which annualisation base it requires. A different term or calendar basis can require a different calculation. Our generic Actual/365 Fixed examples deliberately specify 365 and a 90-day term. Do not extend them mechanically to every instrument described as a bill.
Practice questions
Choose one answer per question. Use the stated contract, dates and rate convention. Hypothetical money amounts are USD; ignore fees and taxes unless stated. Round only the final displayed answer.