Exchangeable Bonds and When the Shares Belong to Another Company
Identify the issuer of an exchangeable bond and the other company's shares. Compare cash redemption with exchange and trace which company owes the debt.
In this chapter
Intermediate
An exchangeable bond is debt whose exchange terms are linked to shares of a company other than the debt issuer. In the simple structure here, the holder may exchange the bond for those other-company shares.
That creates two identities to keep straight: the company that owes the bond payments and the company whose shares determine the exchange value. They are not interchangeable.
Name both companies before doing the arithmetic
A conventional convertible commonly converts into the issuer's own shares. An exchangeable instead references another company's equity. The actual contract can deliver shares, cash or a combination, so “linked to another company's shares” does not guarantee physical share delivery.
| Role | Fictional teaching example |
|---|---|
| Debt issuer and obligor | Atlas Holdings Inc. |
| Equity company | Beacon Networks Inc. |
| Underlying security | Beacon ordinary shares. |
| Principal and ranking | $1,000 per Atlas senior unsecured bond; no Beacon guarantee or share collateral pledge. |
| Coupon | $30 annually each 1 January, first in 2028. |
| Issue and maturity | 1 January 2027 to 1 January 2030. |
| Exchange right | Holder may exchange one whole bond for 20 Beacon shares immediately after issue through the maturity election. |
| Coupon rule | Due coupon paid first on an exchange date; accrued interest forfeited between coupon dates; no later Atlas coupons or principal after exchange. |
| Settlement | Physical Beacon shares, with no cash alternative or fractions for these whole-bond examples. |
Assume Atlas owns enough deliverable Beacon shares and can lawfully deliver them. There is no issuer call, holder put, ratio adjustment, fee, tax, stock dividend, settlement delay or default in the worked cases. All monetary amounts are USD.
The exchange value in this simple structure is:
\[ EV=q_XS_B. \]
\(EV\) is USD per Atlas bond; \(q_X\) is Beacon shares deliverable per Atlas bond; and \(S_B\) is USD per Beacon share. Here \(q_X=20\).
The coupon comes from the debt issuer
Atlas must pay the $30 coupon under its bond. Beacon's stock price determines the value of the share alternative but does not make Beacon the borrower. No guarantee is present in this example.
Before exchange, the holder's credit claim is against Atlas. After exchange, it owns Beacon shares and takes the risks of that equity. It no longer has Atlas's future bond-payment claim under these terms.
Worked application 1. Low Beacon shares favour cash redemption
You hold two Atlas bonds through maturity and have received $60 in aggregate coupons in 2028 and another $60 in 2029. At the 1 January 2030 election, the $60 final coupon is paid first. Beacon trades at $40.
The share alternative for one bond is \(20\times\$40=\$800\), below the $1,000 principal redemption. For two bonds, compare 40 Beacon shares worth $1,600 with $2,000 cash principal.
| Maturity alternative for two bonds | Final coupon (USD) | Principal cash (USD) | Beacon shares | Share value at delivery (USD) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Keep cash redemption | $60.00 | $2,000.00 | 0 | $0.00 |
| Elect share exchange | $60.00 | $0.00 | 40 | $1,600.00 |
Ignoring costs and other differences, choose cash. Atlas pays $2,060 that date and the debt is retired. Beacon owes no part of that bond payment simply because its shares appeared in the alternative.
Worked application 2. Higher Beacon shares favour exchange
Keep the bond terms and prior coupons, but let Beacon stock be $70 at the maturity election.
One bond's exchange value is \(20\times\$70=\$1,400\), above $1,000 cash. For two bonds, 40 shares are worth $2,800, exceeding the $2,000 principal alternative by $800.
The holder receives the common $60 final coupon from Atlas, then 40 Beacon shares from Atlas under the exchange instruction. Its bond principal claim is extinguished. The resulting holding has $60 cash and Beacon equity valued at $2,800 at delivery, not $2,860 of guaranteed cash.
| Beacon price (USD/share) | Share value per bond (USD) | Cash principal alternative (USD) | Preferred maturity alternative under assumptions |
|---|---|---|---|
| $40.00 | $800.00 | $1,000.00 | Cash redemption. |
| $70.00 | $1,400.00 | $1,000.00 | Share exchange. |
The equity threshold at maturity after the common coupon is \(1,000/20=\$50\) per Beacon share. At exactly $50, the two principal alternatives have equal value before costs. This is an exchange-term threshold, not a forecast for Beacon's stock.
Share linkage does not supply a guarantee
Imagine Beacon remains healthy but Atlas encounters financial trouble. Beacon's strong share price does not by itself ensure Atlas can pay its coupons or deliver shares. If the shares are merely assets Atlas owns and are not pledged to holders, the bondholder does not automatically own a secured claim over them.
Conversely, Beacon's share price could collapse while Atlas remains able to service the debt. The exchange option becomes less attractive, but the debt promise remains Atlas's under the contract.
Check guarantees, collateral and settlement arrangements explicitly. They can change the claim, but the word exchangeable alone does not.
Before maturity, compare the whole security
A share value above face does not always mean immediate exchange is best. The bond may trade above current exchange value because it retains coupon rights and future flexibility. Conversion or exchange timing may also affect accrued interest.
For cash-settled or mixed-settled exchangeables, read the reference price, observation period and any issuer settlement election. Replacing those rules with “20 shares times today's quote” could misstate actual proceeds.
The two-company map is the essential first step: Atlas owes the debt, Beacon supplies the underlying equity exposure, and the contract tells you how one claim can be replaced by the other.
Practice questions
Choose one answer per question. Use the stated contract, dates and rate convention. Hypothetical money amounts are USD; ignore fees and taxes unless stated. Round only the final displayed answer.