Leverage and What Borrowing Does to Your Return
Follow a debt-financed investment from purchase to repayment, then calculate how asset gains, losses and borrowing costs change the return on your equity.
In this chapter
Beginner
Leverage means taking investment exposure larger than the money you put in yourself. Borrowing to buy an asset is one way to do it. A gain or loss on the whole asset belongs to a smaller amount of your own money once the lender’s claim is accounted for. Borrowing costs also come out of what you keep.
Your equity in a position is the value left after its debt is accounted for. At the start of a simple purchase, it is the part of the price you pay yourself. At the end, the lender has to be repaid according to the loan terms. Your return measures how much your share changed relative to the money you started with.
Follow the money from purchase to sale
Worked example. Buy an $8,000.00 asset with half your own money
Suppose you put in $4,000.00 and borrow $4,000.00. Together they buy $8,000.00 of a divisible asset. The hypothetical loan charges 6% for one year, with all principal and interest due at year-end. Assume no interim cash flows, fees or taxes and no requirement to sell early. The lender is owed the full loan payment under the stated terms. All amounts are USD and the asset is sold after one year.
The lender gets the $4,000.00 principal plus \(4{,}000(0.06)=\$240.00\) in interest. Whatever the asset does in the scenarios below, the repayment is $4,240.00. Subtract it from the sale proceeds before measuring what you keep.
| End-of-year step | Asset gains 15% | Asset loses 15% |
|---|---|---|
| Sale proceeds (USD) | $9,200.00 | $6,800.00 |
| Principal plus interest repaid (USD) | $4,240.00 | $4,240.00 |
| Ending equity (USD) | $4,960.00 | $2,560.00 |
| Change versus your initial $4,000.00 (USD) | +$960.00 | −$1,440.00 |
| Return on your equity | +24.00% | −36.00% |
In the gain case, the asset makes $1,200.00. You keep $960.00 after interest. In the loss case, the asset loses $1,200.00 and you also owe $240.00 in interest. Divide your net change by $4,000.00, the equity you started with. If you had used only your $4,000.00 to buy half as much of the asset and taken no loan, the same asset moves would have left $4,600.00 or $3,400.00, for returns of +15% and −15%.
For this single-purchase, single-repayment setup, you can use this equation.
\[ R_E=\frac{P_1-D(1+r_d)-E_0}{E_0} \]
\(R_E\) is the decimal return on the equity you invested, \(P_1\) is the asset’s sale proceeds at the end, \(D\) is the initial loan principal, \(r_d\) is the decimal borrowing rate over the holding period, and \(E_0>0\) is your initial equity. The dollar terms use the same currency. If you pay interest earlier or receive money from the asset during the year, track those cash flows too.
Change the borrowing cost and keep the asset outcomes fixed
Worked example. A more expensive loan
Suppose the borrowing rate is 12% instead of 6%. Keep the loan principal, asset price and sale outcomes the same. Interest now costs $480.00 and repayment is $4,480.00. If the asset sells for $9,200.00, you keep $4,720.00 and earn 18.00% on your equity. If it sells for $6,800.00, you keep $2,320.00 and lose 42.00%. The extra $240.00 of interest reduces either equity return by 6 percentage points.
At the original rate, the asset had to gain $240.00 just to cover interest and leave your equity unchanged. That is a 3.00% gain on the $8,000.00 asset. At the higher rate it needs to gain $480.00, or 6.00%. Beating the unborrowed return takes more. In this example, the borrowed $4,000.00 must earn more on the asset than the lender charges on that same $4,000.00. If the asset gains 10% while the loan costs 12%, your equity earns \((800-480)/4{,}000=8.00\%\). That is a gain, and it is below the 10% available without borrowing. A capital allocation line shows how financing costs affect expected return at different levels of risky exposure.
Check what the loan can require before the sale
Some loans give the lender a claim against your other assets if the sale proceeds are too small. Some positions must meet a collateral requirement before the date you planned to sell. If a price drop triggers a demand for cash and you cannot supply it, the position could be closed before a recovery. Check repayment dates, whether the borrowing cost can change and how much you could owe if the asset cannot cover the loan. Those terms determine what an adverse price path can cost you.
Practice questions
Choose one answer per question. Use the stated assumptions and round final dollar amounts to cents.
1. Reconcile the gain
You buy a $5,000.00 asset using $2,000.00 of your money and a $3,000.00 one-year loan at 5%. You sell for $5,600.00 and repay principal and interest at year-end. There are no other flows. What is the return on your equity?
2. Reconcile the loss
You buy a $4,000.00 asset with $2,000.00 of your money and a $2,000.00 loan charging 5% for one year. The asset sells for $3,600.00 when the loan is due. There are no other flows. What is your equity return?
3. Find the equity break-even
An asset costs $10,000.00 and the one-year borrowing charge is $300.00. No other cash flows occur apart from buying, selling and loan principal. What asset gain rate just leaves your starting equity unchanged?
4. Update the borrowing rate
Debt is $3,000.00 and starting equity is $2,000.00. The one-year borrowing rate increases by 2 percentage points. The asset outcome stays fixed. How much does the return on equity fall?
5. Compare with buying without a loan
You put in $2,000.00 and borrow $2,000.00 at 8% for one year. The whole asset earns 6%. There are no other flows or costs. Which result follows?
6. Check the timing of a loan condition
A lender can demand more collateral after a price fall. The price later recovers. Why can that recovery fail to help you?