Finance education, free and open.An independent learning project
THEFINANCE ARCHIVES
Finance foundationsEquitiesFixed incomeDerivativesEconomicsFinancial statementsPortfolio management
Home / Portfolio management / The Capital Allocation Line and the Cost of Borrowing
Portfolio management

The Capital Allocation Line and the Cost of Borrowing

In this chapter

Intermediate

A capital allocation line, or CAL, shows the expected return and volatility you can get by mixing one specified risky portfolio with a risk-free investment. Each point uses a different split of your money. With a common rate for lending and borrowing, the slope tells you how many points of expected excess return that risky portfolio adds per point of volatility.

Start with a risky portfolio and a known payoff

Suppose the risky portfolio has a one-year expected return of 10% and volatility of 16 percentage points (pp). The risk-free asset pays 3% with certainty for that year. All returns in the lesson are hypothetical one-year nominal USD simple total returns, including income, before fees and taxes. There are no outside flows or trades. The risk-free rate matches the currency and horizon. Hold the composition of the risky portfolio fixed as you change your allocation to it.

Let \(y\) be the fraction of your starting capital invested in the risky portfolio. The risk-free fraction is \(1-y\). Let \(\mu_R\) and \(\sigma_R>0\) be the expected return and volatility of the risky portfolio, \(r_f\) the risk-free rate, and \(\mu_C,\sigma_C\) the expected return and volatility of the complete portfolio. Use rates and volatility in consistent units.

\[ \mu_C=r_f+y(\mu_R-r_f),\qquad \sigma_C=y\sigma_R\quad (y\ge0). \]

The risk-free payoff is fixed, so it contributes no return variance or covariance with the risky payoff. Half the risky exposure gives half the spread. For \(0\le y\le1\) you’re splitting money between the two. If you can borrow at the same rate, \(y>1\) continues the same line.

Worked case. Start halfway and read the slope

On $10,000.00 of starting capital, put $5,000.00 in each investment. Expected gains are $500.00 and $150.00. The expected return is 6.50% and the volatility is \(0.50(16)=\) 8.00 pp. With all your money in the risky portfolio, the point moves to 10% and 16 pp. At zero risky exposure, the point is 3% and zero volatility.

With expected return on the vertical axis and volatility on the horizontal axis, the slope is \((\mu_R-r_f)/\sigma_R=(10-3)/16=0.4375\). Each additional point of volatility along this segment buys 0.4375 points of expected return. The intercept is the known 3% return available without taking risky exposure. Among several risky portfolios, the tangency portfolio gives the steepest line from that same saving rate.

Put the borrowing rate on the leveraged segment

Worked case. Use the same borrowed dollars at three rates

With $10,000.00 of your own money, borrow $5,000.00 to invest $15,000.00 in the risky portfolio. The risky weight is 1.50 and the financing weight is −0.50. Volatility on your own capital is \(1.50(16)=24.00\) pp. The expected risky gain is $1,500.00. Subtract the interest on the $5,000.00 loan to get the expected gain on your own money. The loan principal repaid equals the amount originally borrowed.

If \(r_b\) is the known one-year borrowing rate, then for \(y>1\),

\[ \mu_C=y\mu_R-(y-1)r_b=\mu_R+(y-1)(\mu_R-r_b). \]

That gives slope \(S_b=(\mu_R-r_b)/\sigma_R\) for the part of the chart beyond the fully risky portfolio, where \(S_b\) is the expected-return change per point of volatility on that segment. The segment for \(0\le y\le1\) still uses the saving rate.

One-year borrowing rateInterest (USD)Expected gain on own capital (USD)Expected return on own capitalVolatility (pp)
3%$150.00$1,350.0013.50%24.00
7%$350.00$1,150.0011.50%24.00
12%$600.00$900.009.00%24.00

At 7%, the slope beyond \(y=1\) falls to \((10-7)/16=0.1875\). At 12% it becomes −0.125. That last leveraged allocation gives lower expected return and higher volatility than the fully risky portfolio. Even though the loan is the same size, its rate changes the decision.

A line from three percent at zero volatility to ten percent at sixteen points. At twenty-four points, rates of three, seven and twelve percent give returns of 13.5, 11.5 and nine percent.
All three borrowing scenarios start at the same risky-portfolio point. Only the part to its right changes.

The illustration assumes fixed financing over the year. A borrowing limit stops the line at the maximum allowed \(y\). Variable financing costs or a requirement to reduce positions after losses changes the payoff. Read the leverage example for how borrowing changes the gain or loss on your own money.

Practice questions

Choose one answer per question. Round only the final result where needed.

1. Allocate part of the capital

The risk-free rate is 2%. A risky portfolio has expected return of 8% and volatility of 12 pp. What pair do you get with 25% in the risky portfolio?

Question 1 choices

A is correct

  • A. The weighted return is \(0.75(2\%)+0.25(8\%)=3.50\%\). Risky exposure contributes one quarter of 12 pp.
  • B. This puts the right weight on volatility and leaves the risky expected excess return out.
  • C. This describes a 50/50 allocation.

2. Read the slope

The risk-free rate is 3%. The risky portfolio has expected return of 9% and volatility of 15 pp. What’s the slope on the saving segment?

Question 2 choices

B is correct

  • A. This divides total expected return by volatility.
  • B. Divide six points of excess return by 15 points of volatility.
  • C. This divides volatility by excess return, reversing the axes.

3. Use the borrowing rate

A risky portfolio has expected return of 9%. The saving rate is 2% and borrowing costs 5%. What’s the expected return with a risky weight of 1.20?

Question 3 choices

C is correct

  • A. This prices the borrowing at the 2% saving rate.
  • B. This gives 120% of the risky return and leaves out the financing cost.
  • C. The expected return is \(1.20(9\%)-0.20(5\%)=9.80\%\).

4. Locate the kink

Where do the saving segment and the higher-rate borrowing segment meet?

Question 4 choices

A is correct

  • A. At a risky weight of one there is no amount lent or borrowed.
  • B. The intercept belongs to the saving segment.
  • C. A 50% risky weight still leaves half the money in the risk-free investment.

5. Read a flat borrowing segment

Borrowing costs exactly as much as the risky portfolio’s expected return. How does leverage change expected return and volatility?

Question 5 choices

B is correct

  • A. The financed portion contributes zero expected excess return above its borrowing cost.
  • B. The leveraged slope is zero, while the risky exposure grows.
  • C. The larger exposure increases the spread even when expected return is unchanged.

6. Translate an exposure limit

The risky portfolio has 20 pp volatility and you are limited to a risky weight of 1.25. What is the largest modeled volatility from the allowed long allocations?

Question 6 choices

C is correct

  • A. This is the volatility at a weight of one.
  • B. This is the additional volatility over the fully risky portfolio at the maximum.
  • C. Multiply the risky volatility by the full maximum weight.

Find a finance concept

Press Enter to see all matching chapters.