Negative Convexity and Why a Bond’s Price Gains Can Slow
In this chapter
Intermediate
A bond shows negative convexity over a range of rates when the price gain from a rate decline is smaller than the price loss from an equal rate increase. A callable bond can behave this way near the point where early repayment becomes attractive. As rates fall, the issuer may decide to redeem the bond. That cuts off some coupons the investor would otherwise keep receiving, and the price rises more slowly over that range.
Use the same pricing model on all three curves
For two equal benchmark-curve shocks, let \(h\) be their positive size in annual decimal units, \(P_0\) the full price at the base curve, \(P_-\) the full price with yields down by \(h\), and \(P_+\) the full price with yields up by \(h\). In a curve-based model, estimate convexity with
\[ C_{\mathrm{eff}}\approx\frac{P_-+P_+-2P_0}{P_0h^2}. \]
If the average of the two shocked prices is below \(P_0\), the numerator is negative. If it is higher, the numerator is positive. The result is usually quoted in years squared, on the annual rate basis used for the shock.
Our example uses a synthetic USD annual-effective benchmark spot curve at one, two and three years. It is flat within each case and linearly interpolated in spot rates. The pricing model keeps spread and volatility at zero and applies the scenario rate to both valuation today and refinancing at the exercise dates. All payments are USD. The bond pays $60.00 each year on $1,000.00 face, with maturity at year three. The issuer may use optional redemption just after the coupon at year one for $1,020.00 or at year two for $1,010.00. No fees, taxes or default losses apply.
Worked application 1. Put the base near the exercise boundary
Use a 5.00% base curve and a parallel 50 bp shock in either direction. At 4.50%, continuing at the year-one decision costs \((60+\min(1{,}010,1{,}060/1.045))/1.045\), or $1,023.92. Calling for $1,020.00 is cheaper, so discount $1,080.00 one year. At 5.00% and 5.50%, continuing at both call dates costs less than exercise, so price the three originally scheduled payments.
| Curve rate | Exercise outcome | Full price | Move vs. base |
|---|---|---|---|
| 4.50% | Year-one call | $1,033.4928 | +$6.2603 |
| 5.00% | Held to maturity in the model | $1,027.2325 | $0.0000 |
| 5.50% | Held to maturity in the model | $1,013.4897 | −$13.7428 |
The down-shock gain is roughly $6.26, and the equal up shock costs roughly $13.74. Add the unrounded changes to get a second difference of −$7.4825. Divide by the unrounded base price times \(0.005^2\). The result is about −291.36 years squared. This finite difference covers the exercise boundary where the payment path changes.
Worked application 2. Use the same bond when the call is expensive
Start at 7.00% and keep the 50 bp shocks and all contract terms. Even the down shock leaves 6.50%. The value of continuing after year one is $990.90 at that rate, below $1,020.00, and year-two continuation is below $1,010.00 as well. Both calls also remain unused under the other two curves.
| Curve rate | Full price | Move vs. base |
|---|---|---|
| 6.50% | $986.7576 | +$13.0008 |
| 7.00% | $973.7568 | $0.0000 |
| 7.50% | $960.9921 | −$12.7647 |
Now the second difference is +$0.2361, and effective convexity is about 9.70 years squared. Cash flows stay fixed over the shock window, giving the same discounting curvature as a straight bond.
How to interpret the second difference
A negative reading can still go with a rising price when yields fall. It tells you that the rise is smaller than the price decline for the matching shock. A symmetric effective duration averages the price response across both directions. If the two moves matter to your analysis, read the separate shocked prices too. The sign and magnitude of curvature can depend on the call terms, the starting curve, the shock width and the model used to project future rates. With a deterministic exercise decision there can be a kink in the price function, so a finite difference across that point describes the interval.
Practice questions
1. Use the price midpoint
A bond is worth $1,000.00 at base, $1,006.00 when rates fall and $986.00 when rates rise by the same number of basis points. What sign is its effective convexity over the interval?
2. Calculate the second difference
A USD bond prices at $800.00 at base, $804.00 for −50 bp and $792.00 for +50 bp. What is its effective convexity?
3. Identify the limit on gains
Why can a callable bond’s price gains slow as benchmark rates fall?
4. Read a different starting curve
Across a stated shock range the callable bond follows the exact same fixed positive payment schedule as a comparable straight bond. Under the same rate-only model, what curvature can it show?
5. Distinguish direction and shape
A rate decline makes a callable bond price rise. Can a central convexity estimate over the matching up and down shocks still be negative?
6. Hold the comparison fixed
Which set of prices supports a rate-only estimate of effective convexity?