CAPM and How to Estimate a Required Return
In this chapter
Intermediate
The capital asset pricing model (CAPM) estimates the expected return an investment would need to offer for its exposure to the market. Start with the risk-free rate. Add the market’s expected extra return multiplied by the investment’s beta. For an equity investment, you can use that result as a model-based required return.
Match the three inputs
\[ E[R_i]=r_f+\beta_i\big(E[R_M]-r_f\big). \]
\(E[R_i]\) is the asset’s CAPM-implied expected return and \(E[R_M]\) is the expected return on the market portfolio. \(r_f\) is the risk-free return for the same horizon and currency. \(\beta_i\) is the asset’s unitless sensitivity to the market. The term \(E[R_M]-r_f\) is the expected market risk premium, the extra expected return from holding the market above the matched risk-free asset. A beta of one takes the whole premium, and a beta of zero takes none under the model.
Use the same period, currency and return definition for the two rates. The examples use hypothetical one-year nominal USD simple total returns, including income, before fees and taxes. The one-year risk-free rate is certain in the setup. The beta is estimated against a broad equity market proxy used for both cases. The proxy represents the market for the illustration.
Worked case. Find the hurdle for an equity investment
Suppose the risk-free rate is 3.00%, the market is expected to return 8.00% and the stock’s beta is 1.25. The market premium is \(8.00\%-3.00\%=5.00\) percentage points. The beta-scaled premium is \(1.25(5.00)=6.25\) points. Add the 3.00% baseline to get 9.25%.
Suppose your separate estimate, built from expected dividends and the future stock price, is a 10.50% one-year total return at today’s price. It clears the CAPM hurdle by 1.25 percentage points under these inputs. That comparison depends on your separate forecast as well as the model. If you use 9.25% as a discount rate for a one-year cash payoff to equity holders, the cash flow must also be measured in nominal USD and carry the risk represented by the beta.
Test an input that can change the conclusion
Worked case. Raise the expected market premium
Hold the risk-free rate, beta and your independent stock forecast fixed. Suppose a new estimate puts the market premium at 7.00 points. At a 3.00% risk-free rate that corresponds to a market forecast of 10.00%.
| Model input or result | Original | Revised |
|---|---|---|
| Risk-free rate | 3.00% | 3.00% |
| Market risk premium (pp) | 5.00 | 7.00 |
| Beta | 1.25 | 1.25 |
| CAPM-implied expected return | 9.25% | 11.75% |
| Independent forecast minus CAPM (pp) | +1.25 | −1.25 |
The two-point increase in the premium adds \(1.25(2)=2.50\) points to the stock’s required return. The same 10.50% stock forecast now falls short by 1.25 points. If you change the risk-free rate instead, state what else stays fixed. A one-point rise in \(r_f\) adds one point to the estimate when the premium is fixed. Holding the market’s total expected return fixed would shrink the premium at the same time and produce a different sensitivity. The security market line shows how that higher premium changes the hurdle across different betas.
Know when the model is answering your question
CAPM is a one-period equilibrium model. The standard version assumes investors make decisions using expected returns and variance, share expectations about asset returns, can trade without frictions and can lend or borrow at a common risk-free rate. In that setup they hold the same diversified risky portfolio, and market exposure is the part the model compensates with an expected premium. A security’s own surprises can still change its realised return. A higher beta gives a higher model-implied return when the market premium is positive. The model gives the same hurdle to two assets with the same beta on this basis, even if one has more company-specific volatility.
In practice the market portfolio is approximated, beta is estimated and the premium is a forecast. Each introduces uncertainty. The model gives a transparent way to estimate the cost of equity or compare a forecast with a required rate of return. Other risks and model choices can change that estimate. For example, if a company uses its stock beta to evaluate a new business with different customers, borrowing and market exposure, that beta may describe the existing company better than the new cash flows. When using CAPM as an input to net present value, match the hurdle to whose cash flows you are valuing and what drives their risk. If the stock falls 15% over the year after a setback, the realised return is −15% even if the original CAPM estimate was 9.25%. One observed year cannot settle whether the estimated expected return was right. With a series of realised portfolio and market returns, you can estimate Jensen’s alpha against a fitted CAPM baseline.
Practice questions
Choose one answer per question. Round only the final result where needed.
1. Calculate the model’s return
The risk-free rate is 2.50%, the market is expected to earn 8.50% and beta is 1.20. What is the CAPM return?
2. Read beta zero
An asset has beta zero and the risk-free rate is 4%. What does standard CAPM imply?
3. Increase the premium
Beta is 0.75 and the market risk premium rises by 2.00 points. The risk-free rate stays fixed. How does the model return move?
4. Change the baseline with market return fixed
Market expected return stays at 9%, beta stays at 1.50, and the risk-free rate rises from 3% to 4%. What happens to the CAPM return?
5. Choose comparable inputs
Which input pair best matches a one-year nominal USD equity-return estimate?
6. Read a realised loss
The model implied 8% before the year, and the stock returned −10%. What does that observation show?