The Market Portfolio and What an Index Leaves Out
In this chapter
Intermediate
The market portfolio in the standard Capital Asset Pricing Model is the combined portfolio of risky assets held in the market, with each asset weighted by its total market value. A stock index can stand in for part of that market. The holdings and weights of the index tell you how much of the model’s market it represents.
Add up what investors collectively hold
If one firm has shares worth $600 million in total and another has shares worth $200 million, the first firm’s stake in their combined equity market is three times as large. Count the market value of all the included shares, rather than the price of a single share. A $50 share could belong to the smaller firm if it has fewer shares outstanding. For bonds, use the market value of the outstanding claims included in your universe. Face value is the promised principal and may differ from current value.
\[ w_i=\frac{V_i}{\sum_{j=1}^{n}V_j}. \]
\(w_i\) is asset \(i\)’s market-value weight as a decimal, \(V_i\) is its opening market value in a common currency, \(n\) is the number of included assets, and \(j\) runs over them in the denominator. Values below are hypothetical USD millions. The modeled one-year returns are nominal simple total returns, including any income, before fees and taxes, with no interim rebalancing or change in the supplied claims. The Total Return chapter explains why including dividends and interest matters.
Worked case. Build the market of three risky claims
Imagine a small market whose only risky claims are two listed stocks and a corporate bond. One business finances itself through both shares and bonds. The rows count the two distinct claims on that business. They do not add the business’s full enterprise value again.
| Claim | Opening market value (USD million) | Market weight | One-year total return | Contribution (pp) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Stock A | 600 | 60% | +8% | +4.80 |
| Stock B | 200 | 20% | −4% | −0.80 |
| Corporate bond | 200 | 20% | +2% | +0.40 |
| Market | 1,000 | 100% | +4.40% | +4.40 |
The total value is $1,000 million. Stock A’s weight is \(600/1{,}000=60\%\). Multiplying each weight by the return and summing gives 4.40%. These particular results describe one hypothetical year. The opening market weights also give the expected market return if the return inputs are forecasts on a matched basis.
See what an incomplete proxy changes
Worked case. Replace the whole market with its stock index
A market proxy is an observable series used to represent the chosen market in a calculation. Suppose the available index contains A and B and is weighted by their full opening equity market values. The total covered value is now $800 million. A gets \(600/800=75\%\) and B gets 25%. The corporate bond has zero weight in the index.
The proxy’s return is \(0.75(8\%)+0.25(-4\%)=5.00\%\), compared with 4.40% for the whole market. The 0.60-point gap comes from putting more of the weight into stocks, which earned more as a group than the bond during this year. Another year could give a gap of the opposite sign. Using the proxy for a model can change the model’s market return and the apparent sensitivity of a holding to that market.
State which market you mean
In the textbook model, the portfolio aggregates all risky assets available to the investors in the model. A broad interpretation can include corporate and other risky debt, listed and private equity, and real estate. The risk-free asset is treated separately. Researchers may also ask whether difficult-to-observe wealth, such as human capital, belongs in a broader measure. Its inclusion depends on how the model defines the opportunity set and whether claims on that wealth can be traded.
A real index follows its own coverage and weighting rules. An equity index can omit foreign markets, small companies, private businesses and non-equity assets. Some indexes also weight only shares available to public investors. If only 60% of A’s shares and all of B’s shares are eligible for a float-weighted version of this toy index, the weights use eligible values of $360 million and $200 million. A now gets \(360/560\), about 64.29%, even though the two stock names stay the same. Specify the proxy and its coverage whenever you estimate a market risk premium or compare an asset with that market. To judge the performance of a specific fund, choose a benchmark that fits its mandate.
Practice questions
Choose one answer per question. Round only the final result where needed.
1. Find a value weight
A hypothetical market has risky claims worth $120 million, $80 million and $200 million. What is the first claim’s weight?
2. Use share count and price
Company A has 10 million shares at $30.00. B has 20 million at $10.00. What is A’s weight in the full two-stock market?
3. Reweight an incomplete index
Three risky assets make up 50%, 30% and 20% of a market by value. A value-weighted proxy omits the third. What is the first asset’s proxy weight?
4. Calculate the effect of an omission
The stock sleeve is 75% of a market and returns 8%. Its bond sleeve is 25% and returns 0%. What is the equity-only proxy return minus the full market return?
5. Identify the theoretical scope
What does a stock-only index leave out of the standard model’s market portfolio?
6. Match the amount to the weight
A corporate bond has $100 million of principal outstanding and trades at 90% of face value. What value goes into the market-weight numerator, ignoring accrued interest?